Transfer Pricing in Commodities: Practical Insights from Ukraine
The January edition of the Crowe EMEA TP Technical Session featured Vlad Papakin, Partner at Crowe Mikhailenko, as a speaker and focused on one of the most sensitive areas of transfer pricing practice — commodity transactions and their justification under Ukrainian legislation.
During the session, Vlad provided a structured walkthrough of the Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method as applied to commodities, outlining the key compliance steps that frequently determine the outcome of tax audits. These included accurate and timely notifications, detailed product characteristic analysis, and robust benchmarking. Particular attention was paid to pricing adjustments related to delivery terms, trader remuneration, and payment conditions — areas that are commonly challenged by tax authorities.
Using a practical example, Vlad demonstrated a controlled transaction priced at USD 268, explaining how the pricing mechanism supported compliance with the arm’s length principle despite increased scrutiny from tax authorities. The discussion also addressed the practical challenges of Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) in commodity transactions, noting their relatively limited use compared to other industries.
The session featured an interactive exchange with Xiaocen Wang, who raised questions regarding sources of internal production cost data and the identification of key pricing drivers. Vlad highlighted the importance of internal manuals and methodological guidance in building defensible pricing analyses, while Xiaocen shared observations on APA practices across different sectors and jurisdictions.
The session concluded with a practical case study, illustrating how transfer pricing principles are applied in real-life documentation and audit defense scenarios.
📞 +38 063 466 8242
📩 marketing_crowe_legal@crowe.com.ua
